Home>Peer Review>10 Best Peer Review Tools 2025 - Scifocus
10 Best Peer Review Tools 2025
Peer review tools promote collaboration and constructive feedback, enhancing the quality of work and fostering critical thinking abilities. Below are the top 10 interactive peer review tools for 2025:
- Scifocus - A user-friendly platform featuring real-time progress tracking, customizable feedback, and integration with Learning Management Systems (LMS).
- PlayPosit - Provides customizable feedback options, LMS integration, and engages users with interactive content.
- Peergrade - Streamlines peer feedback with LMS integration and customizable features such as group feedback.
- FeedbackFruits - Works seamlessly with popular LMS platforms and supports anonymous feedback and self-evaluation.
- Ex Ordo - Tailored for academic events, with customizable submission forms and an efficient allocation engine.
- PeerStudio - Utilizes a comparison-based interface for swift feedback, LMS integration, and demonstrated educational results.
- Peerceptiv - Encourages peer and self-assessment, provides analytics for instructors, and ensures dependable grading.
- Eduflow - Facilitates anonymous peer review, simplifies course creation, and offers both free and paid plans.
- Turnitin Feedback Studio - Enhances critical thinking, writing skills, and academic integrity through customizable feedback options and LMS compatibility.
- CritiqueIt - Provides versatile feedback options including qualitative comments, Likert scales, and rubrics, with LMS integration.
| Tool | File Types | Review Options | Anonymity | LMS Integration | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scifocus | Word, PDF | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Free, paid plans |
| PlayPosit | Videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Blackboard | Free, paid plans |
| Peergrade | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Free, paid plans |
| FeedbackFruits | Documents, videos, audio, images | Comments, ratings, rubrics, combined | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle, Teams, Brightspace, Blackboard | Custom quote |
| Ex Ordo | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Custom quote |
| PeerStudio | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Custom quote |
| Peerceptiv | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Custom quote |
| Eduflow | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Free, paid plans |
| Turnitin Feedback Studio | Documents | Comments, ratings, rubrics | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Custom quote |
| CritiqueIt | Documents, videos, audio | Comments, ratings, rubrics, combined | Single-blind, double-blind | Canvas, Moodle | Custom quote |
Choose the appropriate tool based on considerations such as file types, review options, anonymity, LMS integration, and pricing to optimize the feedback process, foster ongoing learning, and enhance student outcomes.
1. Scifocus - Best AI-Driven Peer Review Assistant Overall
Scifocus stands out as an innovative AI-powered platform specifically designed to enhance the peer review process in academic and educational settings. The platform integrates advanced AI models, proprietary knowledge bases, and public academic databases to provide comprehensive support throughout the peer review workflow. This includes facilitating peer feedback, managing literature, and improving overall efficiency.
With sophisticated feedback mechanisms, Scifocus delivers precise and timely responses to peer assessments, significantly reducing the time spent on review processes. The platform excels in guiding users through the intricacies of peer feedback, offering tools for generating constructive comments, refining submissions, and optimizing reviews for clarity and academic rigor.
Scifocus also assists researchers by summarizing and extracting essential insights from peer-reviewed documents, creating concise feedback for effective review management. Personalized recommendations based on user interactions help facilitate the discovery of innovative feedback practices, making Scifocus an invaluable tool for enhancing collaborative learning.
Scifocus offers a robust suite of peer review tools designed to ensure thoroughness, accuracy, and efficiency in every phase of the review process. Beyond simple content generation, Scifocus provides advanced functionalities that empower users to structure, refine, and perfect their peer feedback with ease. A notable feature is its automated feedback generation capability, which enables users to create detailed review frameworks tailored to their specific academic needs. This functionality ensures a logical flow and scholarly integrity from the outset.
Furthermore, Scifocus simplifies the complexities of academic reviewing by assisting users in producing well-organized, high-quality feedback that meets the highest academic standards. For more specialized review tasks, such as drafting comprehensive evaluations or conducting comparative assessments, Scifocus offers expert guidance and tailored support to effectively tackle these challenges. To further enhance the quality of peer outputs, the platform includes built-in tools to ensure accurate citations and adherence to publication standards. These features collectively empower users to deliver publication-ready reviews with confidence, setting a new benchmark for peer review excellence.
Details
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Enhanced Academic Transparency | Specialized features may require user familiarization |
| Optimized Peer Feedback | / |
| Customization for Style Guides | / |
| Time-Saving Efficiency | / |
- Enhanced Academic Transparency:
The tool provides translation annotations and side-by-side comparisons for accuracy, ensuring academic integrity throughout the review process. - Optimized Peer Feedback:
Scifocus generates standardized and relevant feedback prompts, improving the logical structure and citation potential of peer reviews. - Customization for Style Guides:
Whether adhering to APA, MLA, or Chicago formatting, Scifocus tailors peer feedback to meet specific style requirements. - Time-Saving Efficiency:
By automating complex peer review tasks, Scifocus allows researchers to focus on their work without concerns over linguistic or stylistic inconsistencies.
User Testimonials
| Testimonial | Source |
|---|---|
| 'Scifocus provides students with an audience for short assignments, which encourages them to think more carefully about what they write.' | Joanne Messman, Greenville Technical College |
| 'Scifocus helps students give and receive better feedback, which improves their writing skills.' | Julia Burrows, Washington State University |
2. PlayPosit
PlayPosit is a user-friendly peer review tool that enables students to interact with content in an engaging manner. It empowers instructors to create peer feedback assignments, establish instructions, deadlines, and specify criteria. Within a single LMS assignment, students can submit their work, offer feedback on their peers' submissions, and reflect on the feedback received to enhance their final product.
Feedback Options
PlayPosit presents customizable feedback alternatives. Instructors can devise targeted feedback prompts, ensuring students obtain constructive comments for improvement. PlayPosit also supports criterion-based feedback, referencing a rubric defined by the instructor, as well as open-ended, time-stamped feedback through a discussion interaction.
LMS Integration
PlayPosit integrates smoothly with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS), making it simple to incorporate into existing workflows. This integration enables educators to access a plethora of features and tools, facilitating the feedback and review process.
User Testimonials
| Testimonial | Source |
|---|---|
| 'The features in PlayPosit have been well-received in DC Public Schools because they allow learners to engage with content in an interactive format.' | Sakon Kieh, Director of Educational Technology, DCPS |
| 'I am a previous [interactive video platform] user, and PlayPosit offers more options for our teachers, including videos and interactions. I am excited to introduce it!' | [Name not provided] |
3. Peergrade
Peergrade serves as a straightforward peer review tool that simplifies the feedback process, allowing students to learn from one another. With Peergrade, educators can generate peer feedback assignments, establish instructions, deadlines, and criteria. Students submit their work, provide feedback on peers' submissions, and reflect on the comments received to enhance their final products.
LMS Integration
Peergrade integrates with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS), making it easy to incorporate into existing workflows. This integration allows instructors to access various features and tools, streamlining the feedback and review process.
Customizable Feedback
Peergrade provides customizable feedback options. Educators can:
- Assign weights to assignments, sections, and questions for complete control over scores.
- Enable group-to-group feedback, facilitating peer reviews within groups.
- Establish categories and reverse categories to manage which students review which submissions.
User Testimonial
| Testimonial | Source |
|---|---|
| 'This tool is a real time saver for me, and I have recommended it to other teachers. Prior to using Peergrade.io, I was making digital copies of the students' Google Docs, removing their names and passing them out with a cover sheet to complete peer evaluations. I found Peergrade and it simplified the process.' | Myra D., Educator |
4. FeedbackFruits
FeedbackFruits is an intuitive peer review tool that assists educators in creating assignments for students to provide feedback on one another's work. It offers various features designed to streamline the peer feedback process.
LMS Integration
FeedbackFruits integrates seamlessly with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS) such as Moodle, Microsoft Teams, Brightspace, Canvas, and Blackboard Learn. This integration enables educators to access diverse features and enhance the feedback process.
Feedback Options
Educators can customize feedback options in FeedbackFruits. They can:
- Establish instructions, deadlines, and criteria for students.
- Enable anonymous feedback, self-assessment, and group member evaluations.
- Develop assignments tailored to specific needs.
User Reviews
Educators value FeedbackFruits for its simplicity and effectiveness in enhancing student learning. With its user-friendly interface and robust features, FeedbackFruits is an excellent choice for implementing peer review in classrooms.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| - Integrates with popular LMS platforms | - Limited free version |
| - Customizable feedback options | - Steep learning curve for some users |
| - Supports anonymous feedback and self-assessment | - User-friendly interface |
5. Ex Ordo
Ex Ordo is a peer review tool specifically designed for academic events such as conferences, symposia, and special occasions. It provides a platform for gathering submissions, allocating reviews, and managing the review process.
Simple Peer Review
Ex Ordo's software simplifies complex peer review processes. It allows users to customize:
- Submission forms
- Topic structures
- Word counts
This ensures that authors and organizers can collect precisely what they require. The platform also enables: - Configuration of single or multi-track conferences
- Collection of abstracts, extended abstracts, or papers
- Setup of topics, formats, and word counts
Allocate and Review with Ease
Ex Ordo's allocation engine matches submissions to the most qualified reviewers, taking into account:
- The number of reviews each submission requires
- Limits on the number of submissions per reviewer
The platform provides: - A clear marking scheme
- Easy-scoring cards
- The ability to collect mandatory or optional reviewer comments
User Feedback
Customers of Ex Ordo appreciate its capacity to manage complex peer review processes. They also value the platform's commitment to continuous improvement. As Dr. Gana N, Conference Director of ASEM 2022 hIAC, states:
'I have worked with Ex Ordo for the past four years... the one thing that stands out is their ability to take feedback and continuously improve the platform with additional features and functionalities.'
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| - Customizable submission forms and review processes | - Limited information available on pricing |
| - Comprehensive platform for managing peer review | - User-friendly interface and easy allocation engine |
6. PeerStudio
PeerStudio is an accessible peer review tool that aids students in exchanging feedback efficiently. It harnesses the potential of peer feedback to improve learning outcomes, rendering it a valuable addition to educational environments.
Feedback Options
PeerStudio provides a comparison-based interface that allows students to view their work as instructors do. This feature enables students to receive prompt feedback on their work-in-progress, which has been shown to enhance course performance. Instructors can create peer feedback assignments, establish instructions, deadlines, and specify criteria.
LMS Integration
PeerStudio integrates seamlessly with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS), making it easy to implement and manage peer review activities. This integration allows educators to create assignments, track student progress, and access learning analytics in real-time.
User Feedback
Over 38,500 learners in numerous universities utilize PeerStudio to study subjects such as design, writing, and psychology. This platform has demonstrated its ability to enhance course outcomes, and users appreciate its effectiveness in facilitating rapid feedback and revisions.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| - Automates tedious aspects of peer reviewing | - Limited pricing information available |
| - Comparison-based interface aids learners in seeing work as instructors do | - Customizable feedback options and LMS integration |
7. Peerceptiv
Peerceptiv is a peer review tool that unites students to support one another's academic success. It allows students to review and assess each other's work, evaluate team members, and critique live presentations. Instructors also gain access to valuable learning data.
Peer & Self Assessment
Students can provide feedback on one another's work through peer assessment. This practice enhances writing skills, critical thinking, and comprehension of course materials across various disciplines.
Instructor Analytics
Instructors receive actionable data to pinpoint areas where students require additional support, thereby tailoring teaching methods to meet individual student needs.
Reliable Grading
Peerceptiv's grading system, validated over a span of 12 years of research, guarantees that students receive unbiased, dependable grades for their work.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| - Fosters a community of learners | - Difficult to use |
| - Enhances writing and critical thinking | / |
| - Supplies learning data for instructors | / |
| - Unbiased and validated grading | / |
8. Eduflow
Eduflow is a peer review tool that enables students to review each other's work anonymously. This feature makes learning more interactive and engaging while also conserving instructors' time.
Interactive Learning
Students can apply theory by anonymously reviewing their peers' work. This hands-on approach renders learning more interactive and memorable.
Easy Course Creation
Eduflow's drag-and-drop course builder allows instructors to create courses swiftly. It accommodates text, images, videos, file uploads, and more.
Plans and Pricing
| Plan | Price | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | - For small teams and testing - Limited features |
| Paid | Starting at $49/month | - Unlimited courses and students - SSO and LMS integration - Custom data processor agreement - Access to API |
Key Benefits
- Cultivates a community of learners
- Enhances writing and critical thinking
- Supplies learning data for instructors
- Features a user-friendly interface
- Offers customizable feedback options
- Integrates with LMS
9. Turnitin Feedback Studio
Turnitin Feedback Studio is a peer review tool that allows students to review and provide feedback on one another's work. It encourages critical thinking, writing skills, and career readiness while safeguarding academic integrity and deterring plagiarism.
Feedback Options
Educators can create tailored rubrics and criteria for peer reviews. Students receive focused feedback addressing specific aspects of their work, enabling growth and improvement.
LMS Integration
Turnitin Feedback Studio integrates with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS), allowing educators to manage peer review activities, track student progress, and provide feedback within a single platform.
Key Benefits
- Encourages critical thinking and writing excellence
- Prepares students for professional careers
- Promotes academic integrity
- Customizable feedback options
- Seamless LMS integration
- User-friendly for both instructors and students
10. CritiqueIt
CritiqueIt is a peer review tool that makes the review process interactive. With CritiqueIt, educators can generate peer feedback assignments, establish instructions, deadlines, and specify criteria.
Feedback Options
Educators can structure the rubric or criteria with various options:
- Qualitative comments
- Likert scales
- Rubrics
- Combined formats
This flexibility allows instructors to tailor the feedback process according to their teaching needs.
LMS Integration
CritiqueIt integrates with popular Learning Management Systems (LMS), facilitating the management of peer review activities, tracking of student progress, and provision of feedback within a single platform.
User Feedback
While there are no direct user testimonials for CritiqueIt, its features and benefits are comparable to other peer review tools that have received favorable feedback from educators. For example, teachers have commended tools like Kritik for:
- Promoting critical thinking and writing skills
- Preparing students for professional careers
- Safeguarding academic integrity
- Deterring plagiarism
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| - Customizable feedback options | - Limited user testimonials available |
| - Integrates with LMS | - Promotes critical thinking and writing skills |
| - Prepares students for careers | - Safeguards academic integrity |
Final Thoughts
Selecting the appropriate peer review tool is essential for refining the feedback process, fostering continuous learning, and improving student outcomes. The ten discussed tools offer a range of features to cater to diverse educational needs.
When choosing a tool, consider factors such as file types, review options, anonymity, LMS integration, and pricing. Assess these against your specific requirements to identify the best fit for your teaching objectives.
The ideal peer review tool fosters constructive feedback, stimulates critical thinking, and promotes academic excellence. By integrating interactive peer review, you cultivate a collaborative learning atmosphere that prepares students for their future careers.
Key Factors
| Description | Details |
|---|---|
| File Types | Ensure the tool accommodates the file types you require, such as documents, videos, audio, or images. |
| Review Options | Look for tools that offer customizable feedback options like comments, ratings, rubrics, or combined formats. |
| Anonymity | Determine whether you need single-blind or double-blind anonymity for peer reviews. |
| LMS Integration | Verify if the tool integrates with your Learning Management System (LMS) for a seamless workflow. |
| Pricing | Evaluate the pricing plans and select one that aligns with your budget and requirements. |
Did you like this article? Explore a few more related posts.
Start Your Research Journey With Scifocus Today
Create your free Scifocus account today and take your research to the next level. Experience the difference firsthand—your journey to academic excellence starts here.